Case Study: Merging Technology and Humanity for Bank System
Date and Location: June 5, 2019, S-Bank Agile Home Methodology: Theory U and SPT Facilitator: Anastasia Totok
ProjectOverview
In June 2019, S-Bank Agile Home hosted a groundbreaking lab facilitated by Anastasia Totok, focusing on the intersection of technology and human values. Over a half-day session, 16 participants, including technology experts and humanists, explored the psychological impact of AI on individuals. Through group facilitation, brainstorming, and body-based practices, the Lab addressed critical questions about technology’s role in our lives, aiming to harmonize technological advancements with human well-being and ecological sustainability.
Summary
What Technologies Can Help People and Companies Agree Between Them
None: an agreement is a compromise or concession. This is not possible with technology.
Request and expectation management system.
Generative communication, taking into account the needs of each stakeholder.
Focus Question Suite
How ready are we to let technology into our lives?
Where does my data go?
How can technology help self-realization?
What is technology doing to us now?
How integrated should technology be into my life?
SPT 4D Mapping Insights
The analysis involves the facilitation of the SPT 4D mapping process, where seven roles are considered: Human, Technology, Algorithm, Feelings, Earth, Evolution (the embodiment of maximum potential), and Fear (the marginal, often ignored aspect). Participants express their feelings and experiences within the model, transitioning from initial states to final states, guided by their roles. Observers then share insights, highlighting shifts and potentials within the system.
Insights:
1. Without the Human, Feelings and Evolution are profoundly affected, showing how human actions influence both personal emotions and broader evolutionary paths. 2. The Human's emotional response reflects a clear understanding of their impact on the Earth, highlighting the need for environmental awareness and responsible stewardship of the planet. 3. The departure of the Human from the system raises questions about their influence and involvement. 4. The Algorithm is perceived as transcendent, governing not just Technology but all living entities. 5. Evolution triggers consciousness in Humans through interaction with Feelings. 6. The Algorithm establishes unseen rules within the simulation, shaping participant experiences. 7. The enigmatic nature of the Algorithm underscores its unknown influence. 8. Skepticism arises regarding the idyllic outcome, suggesting oversight of the Algorithm's overarching control.
Overall, the analysis reveals deep interplay between human emotions, technological advancement, environmental consciousness, and the underlying influence of systemic elements like fear and the Algorithm. It underscores the need for holistic understanding and consideration of all factors in shaping future trajectories, blending human and technological advancements with environmental sustainability.
Role Quotes
Evolution: from "open the heart for good" - to "harmony"
I felt the human need through Earth's pain. I sensed a shift in the evolutionary vector, and Technology turned from a selfish focus to understanding, turning towards nature. Human and Earth connected through Feelings.
Human: from "anxiety and confusion" - to "love, interaction, connection"
Wild anxiety was felt at a physical level, sending shivers down my spine. It was overwhelming, almost suffocating. I felt the urge to step back and observe from a distance. When the Algorithm revealed itself, it felt like being in a matrix, a mix of sensations: the Algorithm's power and my own power - "I wrote you, and I erased you." In the second phase, there was intense pain from realizing mistakes and the harm caused, leading to a feeling of helplessness. Connecting with the Earth brought slow but eventual calmness and relief. When I, as a Human, was with the Earth, Evolution felt harmonious, its presence becoming supportive.
технологии // из "очень стремительно" - в "познать смысл и во благо"
Мне было все равно что вокруг. Когда почувствовала движение Эволюции, тогда появилось желание взаимодействовать с Человеком и Землей во благо. Давление почувствовала от Алгоритма, у меня был страх посмотреть кто это, но при этом немного хотела познать что это - власть и сила. Хотелось держаться рядом, но не касаться.
земля // из "мне больно" - в "я не хочу этого видеть"
Я держусь на страхе. Моя опора была лежа на полу. Мое время несоразмерно с внешним. Всё, что происходит вокруг мелкая суета. Есть ощущения что есть что то сверху. Когда все собрались вокруг меня, я не поверила этой счастливой картинки, я чувствую к ним недоверие, поэтому не хочу это видеть . Контакт с Чувствами. Я прослезилась и укуталась, касаясь Чувств. Но в конце пошло что-то не так и перебило это ощущение соединение и доверия.
алгоритм // из "хочу власть" - в "гордыня"
Мне было все равно что вокруг. Когда почувствовала движение Эволюции, тогда появилось желание взаимодействовать с Человеком и Землей во благо. Давление почувствовала от Алгоритма, у меня был страх посмотреть кто это, но при этом немного хотела познать что это - власть и сила. Хотелось держаться рядом, но не касаться.
чувства// из "что происходит" – в "бережно"
Дотронулась до страх и человека, так как это и есть я, с ними взаимосвязана. Дальше меня удивили действия Человека, то что Человек вышел из всей системы. Когда он вернулся, мне захотелось гладить по голове и успокаивать Человека, посетило ощущение материнства и стремление успокоить.
страх // из "я везде" - в "тебе не избежать"
Я здесь, и я буду здесь. Человек вышел, попытался уйти, но он вернулся ко мне.
Insights from Observers
The mapping processes were observed by 8 people.
So we can notice those processes that are not visible from inside the system. Observers were asked questions:
where did you notice changes in the system,
where did you see a shift,
what is the potential and bottlenecks?
Observer 1
When Man left Feelings and Evolution, their hands did not close. Without a Man there is neither one nor the other.
Observer 2
I saw the Man cry, I understood this pain, because he caused a lot of harm to the Earth.
Observer 3
When the Man logged out of the system, I thought: “Was that even possible?” He created all this, influenced it, and then abandoned the process and left.
Observer 4
The Algorithm is out of this world. For me, this is about Living things in general, not just about Technology.
Observer 5
Evolution came and touched the Feelings, then consciousness began to emerge in Man.
Observer 6
The Algorithm is the top level; it sets the rules of this simulation for all participants. These rules exist, but they are not visible.
Observer 7
An Algorithm is something we don't know.
Observer 8
I don’t believe in the beautiful picture that has emerged from Man, Feelings, Fear, Evolution and Technology around the Earth. The feeling that everyone was waiting for this, but they didn’t notice something, for example, the Algorithm towering above everyone.
Team host Sophie, facilitator Anastasia, co-facilitator Ani